18 Jan 2011

Plosser Rocks the Bernanke Boat

Federal Reserve 4 Comments

Wow is this as unusual as I think it is? I’m going to reproduce Jerry O’Driscoll’s full post (from ThinkMarkets):

Philadelphia Fed President Charles Plosser gave a major speech on Monday at the Central Bank of Chile.  In the polite language of central bankers, the speech constitutes a systematic criticism of not only current Fed policy but of the Fed’s entire response to the financial crisis.

Plosser’s speech updates Milton Friedman’s 1967 presidential speech to the AEA and quotes from it. “…We are in danger of assigning to monetary policy a larger role than it can perform, in danger of asking it to accomplish tasks that it cannot achieve, and, as a result, in danger of preventing it from making the contribution that it is capable of making.”

In Friedman and Plosser’s analysis, the sole contribution monetary policy can make is price stability. What, in the current context, can monetary policy not achieve? Plosser enumerates impossible goals of monetary policy.

  • Short-run stabilization of the real economy is “beyond the scope of monetary policy.”
  • Attempts at short-run stabilization are likely to provide stimulus when not needed and vice versa.
  • Stabilization policies “risk distorting price signals and thus resource allocation, adding to instability.”
  • “…Monetary policy cannot reverse the sharp decline in house prices when the economy has significantly over-invested in housing.”

Plosser calls for a monetary rule, not just in normal times but also in crisis times. The lender-of-last resort function should be rules-based and not involve credit-allocation or bailouts of particular firms. He correctly identifies both as fiscal policy not monetary policy. He repeats his call for the repeal of section 13 (3) of the Federal Reserve Act, the so-called emergency-lending provision. He also wants the Fed’s balance sheet limited short-term U.S. government securities. These last two policies would have prevented the Fed bailouts of the last two years.

It is radical speech by a Fed president and (this year) voting member of the FOMC. Plosser is, of course, an accomplished economist and founder of real business cycle theory. The speech echoes not only well-known monetarist themes but also Austrian ones (the distortion of relative prices by monetary policy). It is well worth reading.

4 Responses to “Plosser Rocks the Bernanke Boat”

  1. Captain_Freedom says:

    I don’t think economic sanity has entered the Federal Reserve System so much as thoughts of exasperated self-preservation.

  2. Jack Norton says:

    Coming soon to a congressional hearing room near you: Quotes from Charles Plosser read enthusiastically to one Benjamin Bernanke by a Dr. Ron Paul.

    New point: I would love to be a fly on the wall in the FOMC conference room this year.

  3. mule.ear says:

    “That is why I have advocated that the Fed and Treasury reach an agreement whereby the Treasury exchanges Treasury securities with the non-Treasury assets on the Fed’s balance sheet.”

    Is this as bad a deal for the U.S. taxpayer as it sounds?

  4. Steves says:

    I wondered who coined the term ‘Real Business Cycle Theory’ ! It was obviously done to counter the Austrian version. This man is your sworn enemy,trust me. If he is so worried as to make apologetic speeches on behalf of the ‘FED’ then you are making inroads for sure. Just watch out for this man.